How to Find and Evaluate Your Ideal Freelance Writing Niche

If you want to be successful as a freelance writer, you need to select a niche. I wish I could tell you otherwise, but without a well-defined target market, your odds of success are slim to none.

Selecting a niche is not an easy decision to make.

Your search for an answer will, in most cases, result in more questions, leaving you confused and frustrated.

I’ve seen people take weeks and even months before finally choosing a direction. The “expert” advice you read today will contradict the advice you ran across yesterday.

Maybe some of the following rings a bell:

When getting started, stick to the evergreen niches like finance and healthcare.

Pick a few niches to specialize in. That way, if one fails, you won’t have to start from scratch.

Let your niche develop over time. When you first start you’ll have to take what you can get.

Confusing isn’t it?

Technically, there is nothing wrong with any of this advice. It’s worked for other people and it might work for you. But in this highly saturated market, is following the same path as the majority of freelance writers going to set you apart from the crowd?

Probably not.

If you’re in search of long-term success as a freelance writer, there’s a better approach.

This post is a little on the long side at just over 4000 words but I think you’ll find it valuable. It’s not all-inclusive — there’s a lot more to learn — but there is enough information and detail here to help you come to a conclusion.

My goal is to teach you how to evaluate a potential freelance writing niche so that you can make your own educated decision. Today is the day you’ll be able to stop relying on someone else’s advice.

I’ve Walked a Mile (Or Two) in Your Shoes

I understand exactly what you’re going through because I’ve been in your shoes — I still am actually. From a freelance writing perspective, I’m relatively green. I’m not an amazing writer, nor do I make as much many other freelance writers.

However, with over 20 years of small business experience, I’m not new to this subject either. I know first-hand just how challenging and nerve-wracking the process of selecting a niche can be. There is so much regurgitated and trite advice that says “pick a topic you love” or “pick 3 and see what works, because hey, picking one is dangerous”

In my experience, deciding on a target market does not have to be a complicated process. But it’s not as simple as throwing a dart at a dartboard either.

“Bingo! Healthcare is my niche.”

If only it were that simple, right?

Personally, I’ve spent hours, days and even months trying to refine and clarify my target market. It can be a mind-numbingly frustrating process. Seriously.

Over time I’ve discovered a few important things that you need to keep in mind while working through this process and that’s what we’re going to be covering in this post. Things like:

  1. An understanding of your skills and passions. I’m going to assume you have a solid grasp of this subject although we’ll talk about how passion plays an important role in your overall success.
  2. The importance of developing both a short and long-term approach to your career as a freelance writer.
  3. Why selecting a freelance writing niche is so important and how it really no different than any other business.
  4. The specific tools and techniques you can use to assess potential niches and things you should definitely avoid.

If you are in the process of getting started as a freelance writer, you’ll want to read through this entire post. If you’re just looking for help on a specific topic, feel free to jump ahead to the most appropriate section.

Before you get started there is one caveat to be aware of:

Your inclination to skip one of the sections below topic is often a sign that the subject matter is something you don’t want to deal with. It’s a sign that you need to work on the exact thing you’re determined to avoid.

Filter with caution is all I’m saying — you might be skipping the content which is most likely to help your writing business.

Why You Should Play The Long Game

Creating a long-term game plan is one of the smartest things you can do to ensure success in your freelance writing career.

Give up on the idea of overnight success because for the most part, those stories aren’t 100% forthcoming or even entirely true. People love to talk about where they are today but rarely the 3-5 years of tough slugging that came beforehand.

My relatively rapid success with creating a freelance writing income is a great example. I fell into the WordPress space quite unexpectedly. But what you didn’t hear about, were the 6 years I spent learning about WordPress, plugins, themes and various hosting companies in the years preceding.

Set yourself up for success by accepting that you’re playing the long game. You’re building a business, one brick at a time.

That doesn’t mean you won’t be able to make an income right away as a writer — especially if you got some talent. But in the short term, you’ll probably end up doing some writing with the sole objective of making ends meet.

The Truth About Selecting a Freelance Writing Niche

Yep, that’s right, I’m saying it again. You need to pick a niche if you want to be successful.

Every single venture that I’ve been involved in, both online and offline, targeted a specific niche. Let me give you two examples:

In my early 20’s and I had a choice: go back to school or start a business. I chose to start a business.

Luckily it was a franchise which was a great way to learn the basics of running a business. Almost everything I needed to know was outlined in a convenient manual.

Most importantly though was that the business targeted a very narrow market which made the likelihood of success that much better.

Although our business was in the landscaping industry, we tackled a very specific problem within that industry. You see, many homeowners wanted a green healthy lawn but lacked the expertise or time to do it themselves. We offered about six specific lawn treatments. Every one of which helped to keep their lawn looking beautiful, green and healthy.

We didn’t cut grass or prune trees — those were someone else’s niche (less profitable and more labor intensive). As a result of being specialized, the business was generally profitable and simple to run.

The second example is from my early 30s. For most of my life, I had a fascination with the financial markets — equities in particular. My passion for the stock market led to me pursuing a 10-year career as a licensed equities trader.

If you know anything about the stock market, you know that there are a million ways to make or lose money. For almost the entire 10 years that I was trading, I focused on a single specific niche called risk and statistical arbitrage. For a long time, it was a profitable way to trade and as long as you stuck to what you knew, it was possible to generate a consistent income.

Eventually, the niche disappeared and I was unable to successfully pivot but that’s a story for another day. My point is that specializing in one specific type of trading resulted, for many years, in a consistently profitable business.

So how does this relate to freelance writing?

Great question.

Freelance writing is a business — not unlike any other business.

Part of operating a successful business means focusing your efforts. Being a generalist might work (who am I to say otherwise) but I think you’ll find it to be significantly more challenging, less rewarding and less profitable.

One final note on this topic: Just because you’ve selected a niche to begin with, doesn’t mean you can’t pivot at some point in the future or expand upon your offerings. This isn’t a lifetime decision you’re making, it’s a business decision. However, trying to establish yourself in two niches at the same time is just foolish.

Quit trying to cover all the bases because you’re afraid of making the wrong decision.

If you decide on a target market, and it doesn’t pan out, pivot into something more appropriate. What’s magical about this whole process is that by just getting started, you’ll discover new ideas that you never knew existed.

Why Selecting a Niche Is So Difficult

I truly believe that this is one of the most important sections of this post. Selecting a writing niche is one part technical, two-parts mental.

For the next few paragraphs, we going to take a closer look at why the biggest obstacle you’re probably facing is yourself.

You might be wondering how I know this, right? It’s because I struggle with the exact same challenge, both in my writing (outside the WordPress space) and with the digital marketing side of my business.

We may as well cut right to the chase. Odds are, the number one reason you’re struggling to pick a niche is because you’re afraid.

You’re afraid to be wrong.

After all, nobody likes to be wrong. While trying to decide on a niche for this website, these are just a few of the thoughts that ran through my mind:

  • What if I’m wrong and my business fails?
  • If I invest a lot of time and effort into this website and nobody visits it, then what?
  • Will people think less of me if I fail?
  • How will my failure to pick a great target market influence people’s opinions?
  • What if I can make more money writing in a different niche that I haven’t found yet?

What you’ll discover is that these thoughts are completely normal — they are part of the process. But when you’re in the thick of trying to make an intelligent decision, it feels like you’re the only person on the planet facing this challenge.

Roger Jones from Vintage Hill Partners published a post in Harvard Business Review that discussed what CEOs are afraid of. He conducted a survey of 116 individuals and found that the most common fear was being found to be incompetent. The other most common fears were underachieving, appearing vulnerable and appearing foolish.

Having skin in the game can make the process even more challenging. What if you plan on using freelance writing to put food on the table for your family? If you make the wrong choice, will you feel like you’ve let them down?

It’s important to see how this negative self-talk can spiral out of control. Condemning you to an endless loop, where you’re damned if you do and damned if you don’t.

If fear, worry or regret are stopping you from selecting a niche, it’s time to take control.

You need to get to a place in your relationship with yourself where it’s ok to be wrong. It’s ok to make mistakes. In fact, over your lifetime, you may as well accept that you’ll probably be wrong more often that you’re right. And that’s perfectly normal.

Choices that seem poor in hindsight are an indication of growth, not self-worth or intelligence ~ James Clear

So what are some specific steps you can take to overcome this fear? I’ve got two suggestions, both of which I have I’ve found beneficial:

  1. Start surrounding yourself with positive influences. People, podcasts, books, blogs, videos and courses. The more the better.
  2. Hire yourself a business coach.  I can say with relative certainty that any coach who has or had a successful business, will have dealt with these exact fears at one time or another and can help you overcome yours.

Also, check out this great Ted Talk by Kathryn Schulz On Being Wrong.

The Essential Components of a Great Freelance Writing Niche

Now that you understand both the importance and challenges of selecting a niche, there are a few more questions that we need to answer:

  1. With thousands of potential niches available, how do you pick the one that’s best for you?
  2. What’s the difference between a great writing niche and a mediocre one?
  3. How can you assess a potential writing niche before you take the plunge?

The answer isn’t always obvious but with a little research and assessment, you’ll be able to increase your odds of starting off on the right foot.

Passion Outranks Profit

It’s a common dilemma — passion or profit? With a little digging, you’ll find some extremely profitable and in-demand niches. Chances are, you’ve also got a list of topics that you’re passionate about. But how do you decide between one or the other? Is there a right or wrong choice? Is it possible to find a middle ground?

In the short-term, it’s ok to write for money. You’ve got bills to pay, right? When you first start, there is no sense in putting your ego first or deciding you’re above writing about boring topics. That kind of mentality will simply decrease your odds of success. It’s like the aspiring actor living in Hollywood who decides waiting on tables is beneath them. Nobody is entitled to success — you’re going to have to earn this.

At the end of the day, though, passion is what will keep you motivated until the money arrives — it’s what gets you up early in the morning and keeps you awake late at night. Passion is also something that readers will pick up on in your writing. If you’re truly passionate about a specific topic, your enthusiasm will show through and keep readers coming back for more.

In the short-term, write to pay the bills. Just make sure you’re also working a long-term plan in a niche that you’re passionate about.

7 Things That Help to Identify a  Profitable Freelance Writing Niche

It’s true that there are some evergreen niches like finance and health. If you’ve got the knowledge and desire to make your mark in one of these fields, go for it. Just be aware that there is no shortage of competition — they are often the first place that everyone else looks as well.

If you’ve decided to pass over those two options, don’t worry, there are plenty of great niches out there. Jennifer Mattern over at All Indie Writers put together a list of 101 options that I’m sure will spark a few ideas. Or you could head over to TradePub to search for ideas that spark your interest.

Once you find a niche that looks like it might be profitable, there are some specific things you can look for.

Consider the following:

1.  Is There Adequate Search Volume?

A good first step is to determine whether or not there is adequate interest in your niche. One of the best places to find this information is by using the Google Keyword Planner Tool. As you become more advanced and begin researching and creating content within your niche, you might find a tool like Ahrefs or KWFinder

To get started, try plugging your niche into one of the above tools. Let’s walk through a short example using “Digital Marketing” as an example. We’re going to target The United States but you could another specific location if desired. In this example, we’ll use KWFinder.

 

The first thing you’ll notice is that there aren’t many specific ideas to write about. That’s because “Digital Marketing”, although there is plenty of search volume, isn’t a niche. It’s a vertical that contains many different niche markets. If you think you’re going to become an expert in digital marketing, I wish you luck!

Remember, don’t get discouraged, get specific. Try to find well-defined niches that you’re passionate about. For example, Facebook marketing is a topic that has considerable search volume. “Content marketing” is another great example. A quick look at Facebook marketing reveals plenty of potential topics and target keywords.

Spend a little time filtering through niches that are of interest to you. What you looking for are clear indicators that other people are interested the same topic and that there are plenty of specific topics to write about.

There is one situation where it might be acceptable to consider writing about more than one niche:

If your freelance writing niches fall within the same broad category you can still make things work. For example, if you’re writing about social media marketing and break that down into Facebook and Instagram, you’re probably still ok. This is very different than trying to tackle “social media marketing” and “alternative healthcare” at the same time.

2. Beware of “Flash in the Pan” Niches

What the heck does that mean? Well, the last thing you want to do is pursue becoming an expert in a niche only to have it vanish 12 months later. This is actually a really simple concept and it easy to assess using Google Trends. Let’s look two obvious examples:

Look at the relative stability of a topic like “Content Marketing”. You could probably dive into a niche like this without worrying too much about the medium-term stability.

 

Now, let’s assume you’re also passionate about Pokemon Go (don’t worry, I won’t tell anyone). How stable do you think that trend will look?  You can see right away that this is a high-risk niche — interesting to write about today and maybe gone tomorrow.

 

3.  Is There Proven Demand for Content?

The next important consideration it whether or not there is a proven demand for content. Not just from an audience perspective but from a paying client perspective. Keep in mind that content can take on a wide variety of formats including:

  • Blog posts or print articles
  • Ad and Sales copy
  • Website content
  • Whitepapers
  • Explainer video scripts
  • Sponsored posts and more

If there is an obvious demand for content, then you’re on the right track.

4. Follow the Money

Obviously, you want to make money writing in your chosen niche. It would be nice if you had a long list of clients to facilitate that process, right? This is an area where a lot of people go wrong. Here’s why:

Let’s say you’re a stay at home parent (I ‘d say “mom” but having fulfilled the role of being a stay at home parent for 5+ years I’ll be inclusive). After spending all day with your kids you might start thinking that parenting is a great potential niche. But is it?

In some ways it is. However, there are also a few problems to be aware of. Although it’s a popular and well-searched topic, there are plenty of websites in the niche which are happy to accept your contributions, for free.

Writing for free is no way to make money. Makes perfect sense, right?

This doesn’t mean you can’t start a parenting blog that earns you money but for now, you’re looking for clients. And your clients must have a need content and an audience that consumes that content.

5.  Are There Paid Advertisers Within Your Niche?

If there are plenty of products, services and advertisers within your niche, it’s a definite positive. Chances are good that those companies will want to attract new customers in one way or another. These days, content marketing is what is helping them accomplish their objectives.

Another thing to look for is affiliate offers within your niche. One of the most common ways for affiliates to generate sales is by providing valuable content to their target audience.

6.  Are There Authority Websites or Influencers in Your Niche?

Spend a little time researching the authority websites and influencers withing your niche — learn a little about the people who will be publishing the content you’re creating.

Let’s take a look at another quick example of how you might accomplish this.

When I got started writing in the WordPress niche, I was lucky to land a few initial clients. Then I started doing some research and discovered that there were plenty of niche websites who might be interested in hiring me. How did I accomplish this?

Heading back to Google Keyword Planner, I looked more closely at a search term like “best WordPress themes”. With plenty of search volume, I turned to Google. What I found was a long list of websites targeting the exact phrase and plenty of unexpected variations. I began investigating the websites that were showing up in the search results and found exactly what I was looking for.

Most of the websites in my niche were using freelance writers to create content.

Also, many of the sites I looked at had a “write for us” page which is another great sign. I got even more excited when I started researching the individual freelance writers who had bylines.

Many of them had rates posted on their personal websites. This meant there was a good chance they were being paid for their knowledge and skill. Of the published rates I could find, most of the freelance writers in the WordPress space seemed to be charging between .06 and .30 per word. Not too bad.

You should definitely spend some time researching the websites and authors in your niche. If all you can find is “write for us and we’ll give you exposure”, there might not be enough demand for paid content.

7. Does Your Niche Help to Solve a Problem?

Another sign that your niche is viable is if the content you produce helps to solve a problem. Especially if solving that problem involves selling something. If the clients you’re pitching have a way to generate profits, there is a much better chance they’ll be able to afford your rates.

This is also an area where your passion can become a determining factor. You want to be compensated for your time and effort. But the only way you’ll be able to stick to your niche for the long-term is if you feel like you’re having a positive impact on people’s lives.

The content you produce for your own website or for clients, needs to have a genuinely positive impact on your readers. Good intentions and great content trump profit.

A Few Success Stories

Everybody loves real-life examples right? Seeing other freelancers who have been successful in a niche can provide a necessary boost of confidence when getting started.

Carrie at Careful Cents has established herself as a personal finance writer and freelance business specialist. Not only does she run her own site, but she also writes for clients like Intuit, H&R, Yahoo! Finance and Wise Bread.

My friend Gina Horkey is another example of someone who’s writing career began in the personal finance niche after a career as a financial adviser. From there, she eventually branched into helping other aspiring other freelance writers (including myself). These days, Gina and I are working together to take Horkey Handbook to the next level and she is a great example of how your business can grow when you put helping other people first.

Joe Fylan at Joe Can Write was one of a few people who helped me get started working as a freelance WordPress writer. He’s established himself as one of the go-to writers in the WordPress space and is featured on many popular WordPress blogs.

Since we used Facebook marketing as an example of a potential niche, I’d be remiss not to use Jon Loomer as an example of someone who’s established himself as a social media expert. While most of the writing he does is for his own blog, you’ll also find his content on sites like Social Media Examiner. You should also take a look at his early posts. It’s a great example of how content can evolve over time and how your niche does not always need to be crystal clear right from day one.

Finally, one more example of a personal finance expert is Zina Kumok. You’ll find her content in places Investopedia, Intuit, Associated Press and The Washington Post,  not to mention her own website. Her story is an example of how your niche can change over time. Zina, who has a degree in journalism, started as a sports writer before launching a blog to share her experiences with paying off student debt.

Don’t Be Afraid of Being Wrong

These six criteria listed above should be more than enough to get you started. With a little research, you’ll be able to decide whether or not your niche has the potential to be profitable.

I wrote this post because selecting a freelance writing niche is one of the most talked about problems that I come across in online writing communities. People are unsure of how to select a writing niche. They are also worried that when they finally make a decision, it’ll be the wrong one.

The important thing to remember is that there is no right or wrong. There are an enormous number of profitable writing niches out there, you just need to pick one and get started. If you make an incorrect choice the first time, correct your mistake quickly and move on. Consider it experience earned.

Look, if you’re passionate about a topic, quit second guessing yourself. Spend a few hours performing a reasonable amount of research then jump in with both feet.

If you’ve picked a decent target market success is yours for the taking. All you have to do is put in the work, establish yourself as a go-to writer in your space and create above average content. Oh, and don’t forget to run your freelance writing business like a business.

Questions or comments about choosing a writing niche? Let’s hear ’em!

Photo Credit: Unsplash

Leave a Comment